Tuesday, December 29, 2009

Don't Judge a Fed by His Shoes

As we've read to page 187, we've met a man named Jim. Now Jim wears clogs, which aren't normal Fed-wearing shoes. Birdie/Jesse's mother, Sandy/Sheila, insists that Jim is not a Fed, but I have fight every bone in my body to think that he's not. There is just something strange about him, and I think it begins with the way he acts--especially around Birdie/Jesse. Towards the end of the reading when he grabbed onto her arm and forced her to apologize for lying is what really set me off. Now I know that she said some nasty things about him, but it's a pretty Fed-ish thing to thrust physical pain upon a young child just to get her to apologize. Kids don't always do or say what they're supposed to, and I think Jim will have to learn that if he wants to stay with this family.

That's all for meow.

7 comments:

  1. i totally think Jim is a fed too! he's too mean to birdie/jesse, and i think maybe he's so mean to her because he really has hostile feelings for her, because he's a fed!

    ReplyDelete
  2. hmm... While this is an interesting perspective, I have to disagree. I think Jim is just a man trying to do right. He also hasn't had experience with children so he doesn't know how to act around them. I think this Jim being a fed is all unreliable narration.
    xoxo
    Charlotte

    ReplyDelete
  3. I can see why you think that, but I also think Jim is just a regular guy. I think Birdie is extremely paranoid, and even the smallest coincidences could lead her to think a number of things.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Interesting. Are you trying to say that it was a fatherly action, or that it was Fed-ish?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Happy 2010, Shelley! Good topic for debate: is Jim a fed or not? There's clues supporting both sides, I think. We'll talk about this next week.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really thought he was a fed at first too, but the more I thought about it I started to think that Birdie has just been raised to be paranoid about everything and not to trust anyone. I think he's just an average joe/Jim...

    :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. Shelley, I agree with you! I think he is a Fed and I think Sheila is just blinded by love so she can't see it. Jesse has been raised to spot these kinds of people, and she's pretty certain that he's a Fed, which makes me pretty certain that he's a Fed. :)
    I'm really interested to find out if Jesse and I are right or not! Oh and if you're right too :)

    ReplyDelete